The Runaround

Fifteen public records requests. One parent with a printer. No records, apparently.

What follows is the actual paper trail of what it looks like when a citizen tries to obtain the documents the government is legally required to give him. The legally required part and the actually giving them part are, it turns out, two different conversations.

A note on the soundtrack. This page reads better set to the Larry David jam in your head. You know the one. Bouncy mandolin. Exasperated shrug. If you do not have it queued up, we are sorry. We cannot legally queue it for you. But we wrote this with it playing.

Exhibit A · The Quote

Hollywood Police Department quoted a single parent, for their own emails, the following dollar amount:

$240,000 Two hundred & forty thousand US dollars

That is for body camera footage, internal communications, and coordination records — all of which the Hollywood Police Department already owns, on a server it already operates, concerning records it is legally required to produce under Florida Statute § 119.

A separate, narrowed version of roughly the same request came back at $241,000. A request for the personnel and Internal Affairs records of a single SRO (Graziani) came back at $226.08 and was then closed for non-payment. So the going rate for the truth at the Hollywood Police Department, in 2026, sits somewhere between two hundred and twenty-six dollars and a quarter of a million.

$245.45
BCPS South Regional
(unpaid, runaround)
$226.08
HPD, Graziani personnel file
(closed — non-payment)
$241,000
Hollywood PD, narrowed
(pending)
$240,000
Hollywood PD, broad
(stalled)

The legal basis for a quarter-million-dollar estimate from a municipal police department, for emails they already have, on hardware they already own, is — well. We're waiting.

Exhibit B · Happy Birthday!

In which a parent learns he is still employed at Broward County Public Schools, nine years after he stopped being employed at Broward County Public Schools.

On March 24, 2026, BCPS responded to public records request 2526-00903. The response produced a document. The document was an email. The email was from a retirement advisor named Fernando E. Recalde at First Retirement Services, sent on July 22, 2025, to the address michael.corva@browardschools.com.

The subject line was "Happy Birthday!"

Happy Birthday email from Fernando Recalde at First Retirement Services sent to michael.corva@browardschools.com on July 22, 2025

Michael Corva left Broward County Public Schools nine years before this email was sent. The mailbox it was sent to should have been deprovisioned in 2016. It was not. It was active, receiving external mail, accepting CAUTION-flagged external-source messages, and being indexed by the BCPS mail system, in July of 2025. In March of 2026, when a public records request was filed for the emails associated with his account, that same BCPS mail system handed the birthday greeting right back to him.

The Broward County Public Schools records system, in other words, delivered the proof that the Broward County Public Schools records system should have deleted this mailbox nine years ago. One BCPS system destroyed the alibi of the other BCPS system in a single machine-generated response to a public records request.

A nine-year-old mailbox receives a birthday card. The birthday card is preserved. The mailbox is not. A request is filed. The birthday card comes back. The universe winks.

Exhibit C · The Ghost Request

Somebody filed a public records request in my name, and it was not me.

On February 17, 2026, an unknown actor at or near the Hollywood Police Department submitted a public records request — reference number 5748961 — using Michael Corva's email address and identifying information, without his knowledge or authorization. Florida Statute § 817.568 calls this Criminal Use of Personal Identification Information. The City of Hollywood calls it request number 5748961. The City then closed it with no action and directed the resulting complaint to civil court.

Identity theft in a municipal records office is, apparently, just paperwork.

Exhibit D · The Records That Do Not Exist (We Have Them)

Requests that came back empty in defiance of documents we already have.

Request 2526-00784 · BCPS Public Records · Feb 18, 2026
Asked for: Alan Strauss's directive email instructing BCPS staff that all communications regarding Michael Corva should route "through me."
BCPS response: zero results. No such email exists in the system.

Separately, in our possession, also from BCPS: a Strauss email dated Feb 12, 2026, in which Strauss himself issues the directive. The email that does not exist contradicts the email that does.
Request P062517-021226 · Hollywood PD · Feb 12, 2026
Asked for: Internal Affairs report for the Oct 29, 2025 complaint.
HPD response: closed — no records found. IA states no investigation exists involving Michael Corva.

Separately: an official IA receipt issued by HPD for complaint #33-2602-23339, dated Feb 18, 2026. That complaint was subsequently described as "closed" by Sgt. Jonathan Baluja in a statement made to FDLE Special Agent Claudia Mulvey on Feb 20, 2026. The complaint that does not exist was reported closed two days after the complaint that does not exist was filed.

These documents do not exist. We have them. They do not exist. We have them.

Exhibit E · Who Is A. Del Barrio?

This question was not asked by a parent. It was asked by the Chief Student Services Officer of Broward County Public Schools.

On January 29, 2026, at 7:25:40 PM, Saemone Hollingsworth — Chief Student Services Officer for Broward County Public Schools — emailed five BCPS executives. The subject was "Fw: Recap for 1/29." The body of the email, in its entirety, was the following four words:

"Who is A. Del Barrio?"

A. Del Barrio is listed, in various BCPS documents, as the Director of Family Counseling for Broward County Public Schools. Directing family counseling is, in its role description, precisely the kind of thing that the office of the Chief Student Services Officer would know something about. On January 29, 2026, the Chief Student Services Officer, on official BCPS email, asked her own colleagues, on official BCPS email, to tell her who this person was.

We are not writing a Curious Case. The Chief Student Services Officer is writing a Curious Case. We are merely publishing it. The dedicated case page is coming and will be anchored to this email as Exhibit 1.

When the Chief Student Services Officer of a half-billion-dollar school district does not know who her Director of Family Counseling is, somebody should probably figure out who her Director of Family Counseling is. We have made a request. We will publish the response.

The Full Tracker

Every request. Every status. Every dollar amount. As of April 13, 2026. Updated as productions come in.

#ReferenceAgencyDateRequestStatusFees
1email chain BCPS South Regional 2026-02-04 Documented concerns logged by Alan Strauss; complaints database; HPD comms; student recordsRunaround. Strauss centralized communications. Kushner falsely claimed records sent to "your attorney." Stalled $245.45
2aPD‑2026‑31 Marco Island PD 2026-02-13 SIM swap fraud records (Sept 22–23, 2025)Referred to CCSO incident #MP25092200094778. Completed
2bPD‑2026‑32 Marco Island PD 2026-02-20 Additional records, same incidentMIPD holds no records. Completed
3P112579‑021326 Collier County SO 2026-02-13 CAD, 911 audio, body cam for MP25092200094778911 audio produced via portal. Completed
4pending Hollywood PD unknown Body cam, internal comms, coordination (broad)Fee designed to deny access. Subpoena alternative under consideration. $240k Quote $240,000
4aP062712‑021926 Hollywood PD 2026-02-19 CAD, audio, MDT logs for C2025-141 (Oct 11, 2025)No clarification; may need resubmit. Likely Closed
4cW062800‑022226 City of Hollywood 2026-02-22 Records re: "ghost request" #5748961Challenges unauthorized request filed under your name. Pending
4fP062420‑021121 Hollywood PD BWC 2026-02-20 Body worn camera footageAxon link sent Mar 5, 2026. Completed
4gP063356‑030926 Hollywood PD 2026-03-09 Graziani personnel / IA reportsCan resubmit or use DOAH subpoena. Closed — Non‑Payment $226.08
4iW063529‑031326 City of Hollywood 2026-03-13 All city emails mentioning "Michael Corva"Search terms provided (Kushner, Graziani, etc.). Awaiting production. Pending — Narrowed $241,000
4kW063539‑031326 City of Hollywood 2026-03-13 Emails: Lorraine/Matthew Corva, Rumbold, ValenciaFamily & attorney emails. City asked for specific search terms. Pending — Boolean
4lP062517‑021226 Hollywood PD 2026-02-12 IA report for Oct 29, 2025 complaintIA did not investigate any case involving you. Closed — No Records
4mP063526‑031326 Hollywood PD 2026-03-13 Surveillance / ALPR + all Graziani emails (merged)User refused DOB; pending production or motion to compel. Active — Fees TBD
4n Hollywood PD (IA) 2026-03-?? IA complaint Case #33‑2510‑151427Key: Graziani requested officers; you were cordial; conflict noted. Produced
62526‑00751 BCPS Public Records 2026-02-11 Apollo MS ↔ Hollywood PD comms (9/1/25–1/1/26)Invoked FERPA; district deferred. Pending
72526‑00784 BCPS Public Records 2026-02-18 Strauss directive email ("all comms through me")Contradicts Strauss's own Feb 12 email. Closed — Zero Results
82526‑00791 BCPS Public Records 2026-02-17 All emails mentioning "parent Michael Corva"682 pages obtained (via OneDrive). Completed
8aHR BCPS HR 2026-03-06 Michael Corva employee file (#P00076801)ID provided Mar 10; still pending. Awaiting Production
8b2526‑00862 BCPS Public Records 2026-03-06 Khandia Smith communications with BCPS staffKey coordinator. Pending
8c2526‑00866 BCPS Public Records 2026-03-06 Desha Rodriguez personnel fileHR requested ID; now cost estimate limbo. Cost Confirmation TBD
8d2526‑00869 BCPS Public Records 2026-03-09 Graziani communications with BCPS employees Processing
8j2526‑00877 BCPS Public Records 2026-03-12 Baylee file, Cecibel instruction, call logsMissing Jul, Aug, Sep, Dec 2025 for Apollo. Partial — Missing Months
8k2526‑00903 BCPS Public Records mid-Mar 2026 FRS / retirement emailsThis is how the Happy Birthday email came back. BCPS email still active in 2025 — 9 years after leaving. Completed
95748961 City of Hollywood 2026-02-15 False police report complaint (C2025-141)The ghost request. Closed — no action. Closed — No Action
13OIG 26‑018‑P Broward OIG 2026-03-15 Records re: Complaint #2025-110111Redacted records produced Mar 17. Completed
15PRR 26‑176 FL Dept. of Education 2026-03-10 Records re: 2026-020012 Complaint Response (OIG letter #10574)Took 27 days just to acknowledge. Acknowledged Apr 6

Case references: DOAH Nos. 26-001279E & 26-001280E. Every row on this table is a request a parent filed, on paper, using the rights Florida law grants every citizen. Every fee listed is money a public agency asked a private citizen to pay, for emails that citizen was legally entitled to obtain. The table is updated as productions come in. The table is not shrinking.